Shadows of Firsthaven: An AAR

In yesterday’s post, we laid the ground work for a cloak and dagger downtime session of D&D set in the last days of the peace of Firsthaven. Today we recount how’d that work out us?

The action started with Druggo spending Day One moving around the harbor, the northern merchants quarters, and the busier taverns. He spreads some rumors, watches for strange faces, and asks questions that sound like idle chatter even as they touch on important military matters. He picks up some rumors of his own and spots two characters that are unusually suspicious, the first is a merchant taking suspicious silver payments for no real service and the other is a man in a brown cloak asking about traffic patterns around the harbor. He opts to follow the harbor stranger that evening and this leads him to a message drop at a public well.

This brings us to the first choice for the player. Does Druggo watch the drop, investigate the merchant, or lurk around the taverns listening to see if his false rumors are circulating? The merchant is a waste of time, but the players opted to watch the well and that earns them a tick (1 / 8), and another lead. A boy drops a message, which is picked up by a man in a brown cloak, whom the players opt to follow, rather than the boy, and he takes a circuitous path to a two-story plain residence for another tick (2 / 8).

At this point, Druggo has identified three of the five members of the cabal. He knows brown cloak and the boy are involved in something nefarious, and has identified one of the two agents. Neither he nor we care if that’s the one looking for Cain or the one looking for Dru, and we don’t have to decide until we need something concrete and specific. What Druggo doesn’t have is the full picture, the full network, or concrete evidence. It’s all suspicion so far, but at least he knows he is onto something. He is a hunter, and he is on the scent, and he knows the important of patience and picking his moment.

Night Two comes around, and the players decide to go for broke. Druggo attempts to break into the house, but his little halfling arms aren’t up to the task, and he fails a climb walls check only to alert Mr. Brown Cloak to his presence. The thief rules are so flexible, and at 10th level you’ve got really good chances of success for all of these activities. I had four checks lined up, and a really bad roll of 95 blew the second one. Had Druggo have made the third (search for traps) he would have found concrete evidence of the conspiracy (that I would have improvised on the spot), but still needed a fourth move silent check to escape undetected. A failure on those would have led to a fight in the darkened house. As it is, the early failure earned Druggo him no ticks, and will incur a penalty on future attempts to tail suspects because they now know they are being watched. You have to punish failure somehow, right?

One thing that deserves a mention is Druggo’s own infosec. He is a loner out there, but at this point realized if anything happened to him, then everything he had learned would be lost. So he retreats to his quarters at the North Gate to get some rest and bring his friend Floydio up to date on his progress. More importantly, this way he might have some cavalry coming to the rescue if he gets in over his head.

After a few hours of sleep, Druggo decides to spend Day Three watching the house. Several furtive character come and go, including a woman in a brown dress (3 / 8), and since this is a stake-out – and halflings are made for hiding – there is no penalty on the Hide in Shadows check that I used as a proxy for being spotted.

For Night Three, the players are now running behind Hooja, who has suffered no real losses. His clock (4 / 8) is halfway filled and something has to break for the players or Druggo might find himself on the wrong end of an ambush on Day Five. He can:

  1. Spend the evening making a second attempt on Mr. Brown Cloak’s house – picking locks instead of climbing this time, but still with a penalty because the homeowner is on full castle doctrine alert.
  2. Go back and watch the well to see if he can spot anyone seen at Mr. Brown Cloak’s door. This was the red-herring for the turn.
  3. Go drinking. He earned it, and it would be a good idea to check up on the rumors he planted back on Day One.

The players opted to make a second attempt on Mr. Brown Cloak’s house, this time skipping the climbing.  A pick locks to get in, move silently to avoid disturbing anyone, and a find traps check to see what he could scrounge by way of evidence and Druggo easily passed all three.  What he found was a safehouse that had been burned and stripped of every bit of incriminating evidence except for the secret door in the root cellar that lead down into the caverns and sewers beneath the city.  Realizing he had uncovered a possible infiltration network, Druggo resolved to get this information into Chaz’s hands as soon as possible.  Thesis required another hide in shadows check, which is child’s play for a halfling in an elven Cloak.

Chaz dispatched Druggo, Tupo (F5), and ten picked me of the militia to track the route from root cellar to harbor caves, and I decided there would be a ten percent chance of catching up to Hooja skulking about,  a 25 percent chance of running into an ambush, and. 60 percent chance they found nothing but the path through the maze to the seaside cave opening.  They found the boring one and had time to seal up the tunnel and both ends, nab a few low level operatives by snatching the boy up and questioning him.

The end result of the game?  Moriva was forced to scratch infiltration through the sea caves off he lost of strategies, and that freed up more men for the battle itself.  Druggo entered the fight slightly wounded, and Hooja managed to fulfill one of his goals.  But nailing down the location of the Homestone proved redundant as Moriva just expended a commune spell to get the same Intel the morning of.

Ultimately, it was a minor victory for Team Firsthaven, and while it didn’t play a massive role in the subsequent fight, it did tip things just a little bit toward the defenders?  Maybe just enough to sway a close run thing their way, but you’ll have to decide that for yourself.

Oh, and you can read the full thread here as least while x.com survives the upcoming political purges.

Leave a Reply

Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Nomad Blog by Crimson Themes.